Family-owned · Serving Texas
What Can I Do If My Roof Insurance Claim Is Denied or Underpaid?
If your roof insurance claim is denied or underpaid, start by asking your insurance company for the reason in writing. Then ask for a second look, from a different adjuster if you can. Still disagree? You can use your policy's appraisal clause, hire a licensed public adjuster or talk to an attorney. Each route has its own costs and trade-offs.
Four routes, what each one costs, and where a roofer fits
The proof behind the promise
Denied or Low
What happens if my homeowners insurance claim is denied?
A denial means your insurance company says the damage isn't covered. An underpaid claim is different. The damage is covered, but the estimate is lower than the real cost to fix it. Knowing which one you have matters. Appraisal settles the scope of work (the list of repairs needed) and whether there's damage. It doesn't settle coverage.
If you're new to roof claims, start with our Texas roof insurance claims guide. Then come back here to pick your next move.
A denied claim and an underpaid claim typically differ in a few ways. Find the column that sounds like your letter.
| Denied | Underpaid | |
|---|---|---|
| What your insurance company says | The damage isn't covered | It's covered, but the estimate is lower than the real cost |
| Common reasons | Wear, age or no storm damage found | Missed items, measurement gaps, depreciation held back |
| Routes that typically fit | Ask again; for a coverage question, an attorney or public adjuster | Ask again; appraisal or a public adjuster for the scope and amount |
Sometimes a low first check is only depreciation held back. Depreciation means the value your roof has lost to age, and your deductible is your own share of the claim. With a replacement cost (RCV) policy, you pay only your deductible, plus any upgrades you choose. On an actual cash value (ACV) policy, you pay your deductible plus depreciation.
So your first check can look low even when nothing is wrong. Read how depreciation can shrink your first check before you decide your claim was underpaid.
Why do roof claims get denied in Texas?
Three reasons show up in roof claim denials: wear, age or no storm damage found. The adjuster is the person your insurance company sends to inspect your roof. Their main goal is to decide one thing. Did a storm do this, or is it age and wear?
Insurance companies typically need your damage tied to a specific storm date. Some adjusters can tell old hail damage from new. Some can't. If the adjuster decides your damage is old wear, the claim is typically denied. That's why your own photos and a storm date help so much.
First Steps
What should I do if my roof insurance claim is denied?
If your roof insurance claim is denied, get the reason in writing first. Ask for the full estimate too. Next, get your own roof inspection with photos, from a roofer you choose. Then ask for a re-inspection, a second visit to look at the damage, from a different adjuster if you can. Keep every letter and note every call.
Many homeowners take these steps first, in order. This is general information, not a plan you must follow.
- Get the reason for the denial in writing, along with the full estimate.
- Get an independent roof inspection with photos.
- Ask for a re-inspection, from a different adjuster if you can.
- Keep every letter and note every call.
Each step gives you something you can use later, whatever route you pick.
What if my claim has stalled?
Texas law sets deadlines for your insurance company to confirm, decide and pay your claim (Texas Insurance Code sections 542.055 to 542.057). If it needs more time to decide, it must tell you why. It then gets up to 45 days from that notice.
In our experience, you'll hear from most insurance companies within 3 to 7 days. Still, delays and stalls are common. For the full timeline, see how a roof claim works, step by step.
Option 1: Ask Again
Can I appeal a denied roof claim?
Yes. You can ask your insurance company to re-inspect your roof or reconsider your claim. A re-inspection is a second visit to look at the damage again. Your insurance company doesn't have to agree. In our experience, most of the time it does. Many people call this a roof insurance claim appeal.
Ask for a second opinion from a different adjuster. We especially recommend it after a visit from a third-party ladder assist company. Those companies take photos for the insurance company, but they aren't adjusters. Send new photos or a contractor's report with your request.
You never have to use a contractor your insurance company recommends. Get an unbiased opinion from a roofer you choose.
Is your claim already closed? It can still be looked at again if you can prove the damage happened in that claim's storm. That isn't always easy. Your photos, your storm date and a written report make it easier.
The upside: asking again is free. The downside: your insurance company is reviewing its own decision.
Can I file a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance?
Yes. If you think your claim was handled unfairly, you can file a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI). TDI's page on getting help with an insurance complaint walks you through the steps. TDI doesn't list a fee to file.
Option 2: Appraisal
What is the appraisal clause in my insurance?
The appraisal clause is a part of your policy for settling a disagreement over damage. Each side picks its own property insurance appraiser. The two appraisers pick an umpire, a tiebreaker, in case they can't agree. Appraisal settles the scope of work and whether there's damage. It doesn't decide what your policy covers.
A property insurance appraiser is not the real estate appraiser who values a house for a sale or a mortgage. This appraiser works on the scope and cost of the damage under your insurance policy's appraisal clause. The scope of work is the list of materials and labor needed to fix the damage. It aims to put your home back the way it was before the storm.
In our experience, nearly every homeowners policy has an appraisal clause. We've seen one in every policy we've looked at for the last 10 years. Check your policy to find yours.
Appraisal with a property insurance appraiser typically works like this:
- You pick your property insurance appraiser. Your insurance company picks its own.
- The two appraisers pick an umpire in case they can't agree.
- The appraisers look at the scope of work and whether there's damage. They aren't supposed to discuss your policy.
- The result is typically binding when two of the three agree, unless fraud is proven.
What it costs you. Each side pays its own appraiser. If it goes to the umpire, each side also pays its share of the umpire's fee.
Why many homeowners choose it. In our experience, appraisal is often one of the simplest, fastest routes. It can reach agreement and get repairs done at a fair price. We have never seen an insurance company fail to pay an appraisal award. The award is the final result of the appraisal.
What it can't do. Appraisal can't make your insurance company cover damage it says your policy doesn't cover. That's a policy question.
Pick an appraiser with years of experience in roofing. In our experience, most homeowners interview two or three appraisers first. We always recommend getting legal advice before you go to appraisal.
Option 3: Public Adjuster
Why would I hire a public adjuster in Texas?
You'd hire a public adjuster to work your whole claim for you. A public adjuster works for you, the homeowner, not for the insurance company. Unlike a roofer, a public adjuster can discuss your policy with you. In our experience, public adjusters in Texas are licensed by the Texas Department of Insurance.
In our experience, when a claim stalls, many homeowners hire a public adjuster or go to appraisal to move things along.
Check the license before you sign anything. TDI explains how to find a licensed insurance agent or adjuster. If you're unsure, ask the public adjuster for their license number and look it up yourself.
How are public adjusters paid?
A public adjuster is typically paid a share of what your insurance company pays. The Texas Department of Insurance says it plainly: "Public adjusters can charge up to 10% of the total amount the company will pay for your claim." TDI adds: "The fee can be based on the total amount of the claim settlement, not just the amount you're disputing."
Ask for the fee in writing before you sign. TDI also says: "If you change your mind, you have 72 hours after you've signed a contract to cancel it."
What is the downside of using a public adjuster?
There are two big downsides. First, you pay a fee, and TDI says it can be up to 10% of what the insurance company pays. Second, a public adjuster is not an attorney.
How is a public adjuster different from my insurance company's adjuster?
Your insurance company's adjuster works for the insurance company. A public adjuster works for you, and you pay the public adjuster's fee.
How is a public adjuster different from a property insurance appraiser?
A public adjuster works your whole claim. A property insurance appraiser works only on the scope of work and the damage, inside the appraisal process. Both can be hired by you, but they do different jobs.
Option 4: Attorney
When should I talk to a property insurance attorney?
A good time to talk to an insurance attorney is typically when you feel the damage should have been covered. It also fits when your contractor finds storm damage your insurance company didn't pay for, or your claim isn't paid or answered. Suspected bad faith is another reason. That means you believe your claim isn't being handled fairly.
Contractors can't give legal advice or discuss your policy. That conversation is between you and an attorney or a public adjuster.
How attorneys get paid. Many reputable insurance attorneys work for a percentage of what they recover, with no upfront fee. The trade-off is that a share of what's recovered goes to the attorney.
Don't wait too long. Texas law doesn't let a policy give you less than two years to sue on it (Civil Practice & Remedies Code §16.070), but the clock may start earlier than you think, and you must give written notice before you sue. Check your policy and ask an attorney about your own deadline.\*
About late-payment interest. We've seen interest paid only a few times. It was usually after a lawsuit or when the homeowner asked for it.
We don't name or recommend law firms or public adjusters. The choice is yours.
Compare Your Options
Should I hire a public adjuster or an attorney?
Match the route to your problem. If you disagree on the scope or amount of damage, appraisal or a public adjuster may fit. If your insurer says the damage isn't covered at all, that's a policy question for an attorney or a public adjuster. Asking your insurance company again is free, so start there.
The table compares your options side by side, including a TDI complaint. Find the row that fits where your claim is right now.
| Route | Who it works for | What it can settle | Usual cost | Often considered when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ask the insurer again | Your insurance company reviews its own decision | A second look at the damage | Free | You have new photos, a report or a storm date |
| TDI complaint | You file it with the Texas Department of Insurance | A complaint about how your claim was handled | TDI doesn't list a filing fee | You think your claim was handled unfairly |
| Appraisal (property insurance appraiser) | Each side has its own appraiser; an umpire breaks ties | The scope of work and whether there's damage, not coverage | You pay your appraiser and share the umpire's fee | You disagree on the damage or the amount |
| Public adjuster | You | Your whole claim, including talking through your policy | Up to 10% of what the insurance company pays, per TDI | Your claim has stalled or come back low |
| Attorney | You | Legal and coverage questions | Many work for a percentage of what they recover, no upfront fee | You think it should be covered, or your claim isn't paid or answered |
Not sure which row is yours? Look at your letter. Does it say the damage isn't covered, or does it pay less than your repair will cost?
How We Help
How can a roofer help when my claim comes back low or denied?
A roofer can give you a second, documented look at your roof. At ARP, we inspect, photograph and write up the damage. We meet your adjuster at the re-inspection and work alongside your adjuster, not against them. The scope of work is the only thing we discuss. We never negotiate price or act as your public adjuster.
A denial letter is stressful. You didn't cause the storm, and now you're told the damage doesn't count. You shouldn't have to become an insurance expert to get your home fixed the right way.
Randal Williams co-founded ARP and is our COO. He has walked hundreds of storm claims. He is an Xactimate expert, with deep experience on insurance claims. Most insurance companies price repairs with Xactimate software. Randal documents damage correctly for your carrier. He has more than $7 million in insurance claim work across Texas, including single commercial claims above $2 million. That's our Insurance Navigator System™: we work alongside your adjuster.
In our experience, a low estimate usually means items were missed, and those items can be added back with photos and line items.
The plan takes three steps:
- Book your free Storm Shield Assessment™. We check your roof with thermal imaging, moisture detection and photos of your roof deck, the wood layer your shingles sit on. Your free inspection comes with our written, detailed estimate, so you know the price before you decide.
- Keep the written report. You get the photos and a written scope of the damage. You can hand them to your insurance company, a property insurance appraiser, a public adjuster or an attorney.
- We meet your adjuster at the re-inspection. We show the adjuster the damage and document it. We attend your adjuster meetings at no cost to you.
One honest note: if our inspection finds no storm damage, you get that in writing too. We won't write up damage that isn't there.
Schedule my second roof inspection →
What can't a roofer do on my claim?
A roofer can help with the damage, not with your policy. We can't:
- Negotiate price or advocate for your claim. Roofers discuss only the scope of work. Most insurance companies price that scope with Xactimate.
- Act as your public adjuster. That's a licensed job in Texas.
- Give you legal or policy advice. That's for an attorney or a public adjuster.
- Promise you a result. Your insurance company and your policy decide what's paid.
- Waive or pay your deductible.
That last one matters on a low claim, because some contractors offer it. Under Texas Insurance Code §707.002, the deductible is yours to pay. A seller of goods or services who pays, waives, absorbs or rebates it without your insurance company's consent commits an offense. Texas Business & Commerce Code §27.02 makes that a Class B misdemeanor. ARP never does it.
Why does my low estimate leave out the rest of my house?
A low estimate often pays for the roof and leaves out what the storm did to the rest of the house. Think dented gutters, cracked siding or a stained ceiling. ARP Roofing repairs the whole house, not only the roof. So we can show your adjuster each damaged item. We document it for a re-inspection or a supplement, which is a request to add items the first estimate missed. We discuss the scope of the damage, never the policy or the price. If you need policy advice, that's a conversation for an attorney or a public adjuster.
We're a local general contractor and a family-owned roofing and remodeling company serving Texas since 2016. As the work goes on, your insurance company gets the photos and write-ups it requests from us. On flood and fire claims, we do the rebuild, and local restoration partners we work with do the drying and cleanup. Still deciding about the roof itself? Read whether to repair or replace a storm-damaged roof.
Honest Fit
Is ARP the right roofer for my denied or underpaid roof claim?
ARP is the right fit if you want a second, documented look at your roof and your roofer at the re-inspection. We're not a fit if you want someone to argue your claim. For that, a licensed public adjuster or an attorney is the honest answer.
Sources & References
- Texas Civil Practice & Remedies Code §16.070: a contract can't set a time limit to sue shorter than two years.
- Texas Department of Insurance, public adjusters: what to know before you hire one: the 10% fee limit and the 72-hour cancel window.
- Texas Department of Insurance, how to find a licensed insurance agent or adjuster
- Texas Department of Insurance, get help with an insurance complaint
- Texas Insurance Code sections 542.055 to 542.057: your insurance company's deadlines to confirm, decide and pay a claim.
- Texas Insurance Code §707.002: the insured pays the deductible.
- Texas Business & Commerce Code §27.02: the ban on a contractor paying, waiving, absorbing or rebating your deductible.
- Texas Insurance Code §4102.163 (cited in the note below).
\ Educational content only.* This page is for educational purposes and isn't legal advice. For legal advice, talk to a Texas attorney. See your policy or ask your insurance carrier for specific information about your policy. ARP Roofing & Remodeling is a roofing contractor, not a public insurance adjuster (Texas Insurance Code §4102.163).
Second Inspection
Get a Second, Documented Look at Your Roof
Picture your next call with the insurance company. You have your own photos and a written scope in hand. You know which route fits your claim and what it will cost you. Whatever you choose, you're making the call with the facts, not a guess.
Not where you are?
- Still waiting on a decision? Read how a roof claim works, from report to payment.
- Check is lower than you expected? See what depreciation, ACV and RCV mean for your payout.
Questions that decide the job
Denied or Underpaid Roof Claim FAQs
What do I do if insurance denied my roof claim?
+
Do I have to accept my insurance settlement offer?
+
What is an appraisal clause in my homeowners policy?
+
What if the insurance adjuster says there's no hail damage?
+
Is a public adjuster worth it?
+
Who typically hires a public adjuster?
+
How much do public adjusters charge in Texas?
+
Start with the assessment, not the estimate
We look at the roof, document what we find with photographs, and give you the written assessment — whether or not you hire us. Then you decide, on your timeline.